Fake sheriff's jury duty warrant scam

A reddit report about a phishing scam that cost someone $2000.0. Learn how to avoid falling victim.

Got scammed today by someone impersonating the local sheriff’s office. Posting this partly as a warning in case it helps someone else avoid the same thing. The caller said I had missed a notice for jury duty and that there was now a warrant out for my arrest. I know I should have caught it. In hindsight there were a lot of red flags. But in the moment they caught me off guard and were pretty convincing. They knew my address and had me look up the number they were calling from to prove it was legitimate. When I googled it, the number actually showed up as belonging to the local sheriff’s office. They also had me read what they called an “NDA,” saying I couldn’t contact anyone or discuss the situation because it was supposedly part of an active case. Then they said the sheriff’s department doesn’t take direct payments and that I needed to post bail through Walmart for $2,000. The story was that Walmart would give me a voucher as proof of payment, and I would bring that to the sheriff’s office where I could then speak to the investigative unit about why I never received the jury duty notice. They also told me that if a Walmart employee asked why I was making the payment, I shouldn’t say anything because of the “NDA” and because there was an active warrant. They even claimed that if someone found out about the warrant they could report me and claim a reward. So yeah… I panicked and went to a nearby Walmart and made the $2,000 payment using my debit card. The moment I realized it was a scam was when I got back to my car and the guy suddenly said there were actually two active warrants and that I needed to go to another Walmart and pay another $2,000 before coming to the sheriff’s office. That’s when it finally clicked. I immediately called my bank and reported it. They filed a claim, but they told me it may be difficult to recover since I authorized the transaction myself. I pointed out that the FTC considers payments made under scam threats to be fraudulent, so they did file the claim as fraud. Fingers crossed I get my money back, but I’m not holding my breath. I also cancelled the debit card used for the payment, changed my phone settings so unknown callers go straight to voicemail. Lesson learned. One thing I’m still worried about: they had me read four pages of text out loud during the call. I assume they recorded the conversation. I’m trying to remember if I gave them my date of birth. I don’t think I did. I’m almost certain I didn’t give my SSN, but I was pretty stressed at the time 😅. Should I be concerned about them using that recording for anything (voice authorization, scams, etc.)?

🛡️ How to Protect Yourself

1

Protect your banking information and use secure connections

2

Contact companies directly using official phone numbers

3

Always verify email senders and avoid clicking suspicious links

Verify Suspicious Messages Instantly

Don't fall victim to scams. Use ScamPup to check any suspicious message, link, or email before it's too late.

Check with ScamPup →

Share This Story

Help others avoid scams by sharing this prevention story.

Disclaimer: This content is compiled from publicly available scam reports and community submissions. ScamPup is not responsible for the accuracy of information regarding specific companies, individuals, locations, or brands mentioned in these stories. Always verify information independently and consult professionals for legal or financial advice.